"Si vis pacem, para bellum." - De Re Militari
In my earlier post this morning I briefly announced and began some discussion and analysis of the new Mists of Pandaria cinematic. I didn't have enough time to go into detail so I'll do it now. As always the CG quality is up to Blizzard's usual level of detail to the point of being practically photorealistic but with a certain 'fantasy' feel. I am not going to uphold it as a cinematic work of art as it relies on many tropes and cliches, but most of them it handles nicely. Comparing it aside the other WoW cinematics I actually would rank it highly because of well thought out use of subtext and content, but it does have some glaring flaws. I have relinked it below and there I go into analysis.
So here we have it, coming in at a full 40 seconds longer than the Wrath of the Lich King cinematic, making it the longest thus far. Because Apple Cider Mage has done an in-depth analysis of the gender depictions (or complete absence of a female presence) in the video I won't go into too much detail on that front. Suffice to say, her critiques are spot on, but I do not think they doom the video.
I should also say that this video really isn't doing anything to dispel the concerns that Blizzard is ripping off Kung Fu panda...and off we go!
Why do we fight? Because its fun when no one actually dies...because we want cool loot? I get why the line is in there, trying to channel the inner Blizzard zen-masters to provide us something akin to a koan and a little Panda philosophy...and yet it felt so generic and cliche that it fell on its face.
First off we have the image depicting the Horde and Alliance in their struggle; endlessly locked in a conflict that is dragging them both to the ground...or to the bottom of the sea. A nice example of showing rather than telling...while it may not be too subtle, its far better than the narrator telling us about some war.
|About as subtle as a boot to the head.|
Here the two ships have sunk each other, foreshadowing the upcoming "change" in the storyline and subtly reinforcing just how fruitless and destructive the war between Horde and Alliance is. Later on, as I will discuss, this is juxtaposed aside the relatively peaceful nature of the Pandaren...and also hints at....
The new Pandaren starting area and new 85 zones.
Ok you are safe now!
I mentioned Apple Cider Mage earlier and while I think she has valid points about the overhyped masculinity in the video, I will commend Blizzard on one factor: the male orc and human actually have the same body as their in-game representative, keeping a certain consistency...but this is not a complete accolade, and glosses over the fact that the depiction of the human is clearly way over-built.
|Krog (right) has some serious fingernail fungus issues.|
On the other hand, the video is wrought with symbols and tropes; the Alliance sailor and Orc warrior are images of the Alliance and Horde that are as old as Warcraft 2. (Really, down to the red, one-pauldron orc warrior). They even show their stereotypes in more subtle ways. The human's first thought is to MAKE something, a spear from an oar, while the Orc's first thought is on getting up and moving forward. I am not going to defend the lack of updating to the modern era with regards to gender isues, but I will note that it is not like these images are a "new" thing to the Warcraft universe.
|Pandas are like TF2 players...don't mess with their hats|
|y u guys break my stuff?|
Using the staff to tweak the balance is just a nice bit of humor but also puts the staff across his body and reinforces the next statement he makes "Bring it on." A direct challenge...anything they break, he can mend...breaking stuff is fruitless.
So in one small scene we've shown the Alliance/Horde that their war is pointless, that the pandas can show them the way, that THIS panda is badass and cares about restoration, AND that the Horde/Alliance should put down their weapons.
|Freud would a few things to say about this...the "Wow..." look on their faces is priceless.|
Then the human hands his oar-spear over to the Orc. Think about this...a new enemy has shown up that is clearly more powerful than Horde and Alliance (as stated previously, the two characters are basically perfect stereotypes of their factions) and they have to work together to face it. For a brief moment the two realize that their fighting each other was futile and useless...and the Panda has taught them that.
Bolstered by this new union, the two attack and promptly get taught a lesson about under-estimating a Panda, who's staff spinning looks like it was basically modeled from a Jet Li movie (I am 99% sure that I could find a nearly identical move in a movie of his). Included is more proof that this Panda is merely toying with them, what with how he almost looks like he is just playing when he fights with them. All while the mist is clearing and the sun is coming out; and right as it comes out the two factions have that revelation of their hubris and humility appears on their faces for the first time. The sun of new thinking has washed away the mist of conflict.
Then we get to see once more that Blizzard's animators know how to make a pretty vista...which I understand is blatant Orientalism and yet somehow I love it.
We end with the reasons we fight, which I still think are cheesy and cliche but fit the passive Pandas well enough. Really, he says that they fight out of necessity...it is a roundabout way of saying "If you desire peace, prepare for war."
Really I do think this is one of the better videos. But each has been so different that comparing them feels like comparing across genre. Cata's was emo and disaster porn, Wrath's was poetic mean to invoke pity and juxtapose the irony of Arthas...TBC and Vanilla showed more of the characters. Mists seems to be mainly subtextual but also a throw-back to the Vanilla/TBC eras, showing the actual "characters" somewhat in action.